Sunday, February 13, 2011

What is art which doesn't have any intended emotion?

This question was posed by Natalie Pozzetti.

Personally, I think that all art conveys some sort of emotion.  The artist may or may not intend to instill a specific emotion in those experiencing the art, but all real art stems from emotion.  Say for example that I created an abstract painting, consisting of swirling, curving lines in various shades of green.  When I painted this, I was feeling refreshed, although I want to know what others get out of it.  Someone looking at the painting might feel a sense of curiosity.  Someone else might see hope.  Although I created the painting while feeling "refreshed," I didn't necessarily want everyone who looked at the painting to feel the same way.  I think it's okay to make art that is open to interpretation.


Question: What do you think about the role of religious art?

Catharsis

Tolstoy defines art as something born from an artist's recalling an emotion, which communicates that emotion to a second party.  Sometimes a second party looks at/listens to/watches/etc. art in order to feel an emotion other than the one she is feeling.  For example, she might watch a funny movie to cheer herself up.  But sometimes, "improving" a mood by not allowing a "bad mood" to exist doesn't work.  Sometimes you just need to feel whatever it is you're feeling. 
I'm a big believer in catharsis, and art's role in the process.  Some people might say that I like to wallow in sadness, but that's not all there is to it.  People are able to feel a terrible, beautiful, wide range of emotion, so why should we try to pretend otherwise?  I'm not saying I'm going to go around crying at people whenever I'm having a bad day, but if I'm sad, I want to be able to sit somewhere quiet and listen to sad music.  I've heard that sad music helps someone who's feeling sad because someone (the musician) has it worse off (and maybe for some what really helps is schadenfreude), but I think that the key is the ability to relate to another human being on an emotional level.
This is a favorite song of mine (and the video is rather nice, too):
What emotion(s) do you get from it?

Video: "Samson" by Regina Spektor, from Youtube